Catelynn is a smart and funny high school Senior, who spent her Junior year pregnant with her daughter Carly. In an emotional journey, Catelynn and her boyfriend Tyler chose adoption, even though their own parents strongly disapproved. They have a semi-open adoption, which means Catelynn and Tyler communicate regularly with Carly's adoptive parents, Brandon & Teresa, and see photographs of their growing daughter.

Although Catelynn and Tyler know they made the right decision for themselves and their daughter, their parents are still having trouble accepting the decision, and Catelynn has been trying to avoid the drama at home by staying at Tyler's house, but that has proven harder she hoped. Catelynn's challenge is to help her family understand her decision to choose adoption, while trying to return to her normal teenage life and enjoy her Senior year.